Wednesday, October 23, 2013

PAPER CHASE: THE FBI’S GREENBRIER BUNKER NOTIFICATION DUTY

Congressional Rubble

“All FBI offices, day-to-day and emergency, should be supplied in advance and on a secret basis, with the location of the Congressional relocation site and with instructions that in the event of a Presidential proclamation calling upon the Congress to convene at the Congressional relocation site, the FBI should inform members of Congress so presenting themselves and so establishing their identity, of the location of the Congressional relocation site.”

- Text from a February 10, 1961 FBI memo recommending the protocol for notifying members of the United States Congress of their emergency relocation site

1961 FBI Text

Thanks to investigative journalist Ted Gup we all know that the super bunker at the Greenbrier resort in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia was intended for use by the Congress in the event of a nuclear attack on the United States. He revealed its unlikely existence on May 31, 1992 in a Washington Post magazine cover story. Not included in Mr. Gup’s very detailed exposé is the procedure by which rank and file members of Congress would have been made aware of the bunker. This post will fill in that small gap in the Greenbrier bunker knowledge base.

Greenbrier-False-Front Door 
Earlier in the year we published a post about government correspondence concerning the sensitive task of notifying members of Congress of their top secret relocation site in the event of a national emergency during the Cold War.[1] The author of the document that we presented in our previous story suggested several options to his addressee on how to handle this apocalyptic chore. One possibility included saddling the Federal Bureau of Investigation with the notification duty. The reasoning behind this particular choice was the concern that the security of the site might eventually be compromised if an ever increasing number of active and former Congressmen had ongoing knowledge of its location. Obviously, nothing was ruled in or ruled out in this one-sided memo, so we (and our readers) were left hanging awaiting another memo that revealed the decision. By virtue of the tireless FOIA filing efforts of GovernmentAttic.org we now have the additional documents that prove that the Greenbrier bunker notification responsibility was, in fact, assigned to the FBI. And, surprisingly, it was not a job that was immediately accepted with open arms by the Bureau.

Observation copy

Indeed, in assessing the White House’s request for this assistance, senior FBI agent Alan H. Belmont argued against it. In an October 21, 1957 internal memo Belmont was more concerned with the bureau’s mission of “rounding up enemy aliens” during a crisis – not helping panicky legislators learn about their shelter accommodations. Belmont also raised the possibility of “some member of Congress” coming to a FBI field office to demand the location of the bunker site prior to the approved disclosure period (i.e. after a Presidential proclamation). He concluded that this scenario would put the “Bureau in a bad light” and imply “that the White House does not sufficiently trust the rank and file of the Congress” with the information.

Hoover and Tolson - 1947

But FBI leadership quickly disregarded these concerns in the form of terse mark-ups to Belmont’s correspondence. Associate Director Clyde Tolson weighed in first by scribbling “If the President wants us to do this, I think it is OK – T.” Director J. Edgar Hoover concurred and wrote the following next to Tolson’s note: “Of course. We must do it if that is the President’s desire. H.”

Tolson-Hoover_Handwritten Note copy

That settled that. And then there was a period of silence while the Greenbrier bunker was actually built. In early 1961, as the bunker was nearing operational status, the issue of congressional notification was revisited in more concrete terms.

Following some bureaucratic revisions, a protocol for the secret notification duty was arrived at between the FBI and the Office of Civil and Defense Mobilization (OCDM). According to an internal FBI memo, the Attorney General was officially notified of the agency’s new responsibility via a letter dated February 14, 1961.

In a March 7, 1961 memo Director Hoover stated that FBI field offices “have been advised of the Bureau’s responsibility in informing Members of Congress, upon their request, as to the specific location of the Congressional relocation site. This information will only be made available to Congressmen in the event of an emergency, when, in the judgment of the President, Congress should convene outside Washington, D.C. The identity of the Congressional relocation site is being maintained by our field offices in sealed envelopes, to be opened only upon the issuance of the Presidential proclamation.”

Hoover 1961 Statement

Hoover’s memo to the field offices—distributed through the Albany, New York office—provided additional details regarding the procedure:

“Attached hereto, for each office, is an appropriate number of sealed envelopes, classified Secret, each containing the identity of the specific location of the Congressional relocation site. In accordance with Congressional instructions received through OCDM, these envelopes should not be opened, except in the event the condition cited previously exists. A sealed envelope should be filed in each copy of your office defense plan as Appendix 25…”

Hoover_Distribution copy

One last bit of business that needed to be addressed was where exactly to store the defense plan containing the location of the Congressional relocation site at the Records Branch of the FBI in Washington, DC. In a memo dated March 14, 1961, Mr. Belmont helpfully suggested that “Bureau File 66-17388” be retained in the Confidential File Room. In 1964 the matter was revisited in the form of a memo requesting confirmation that the file still needed to reside in what was now called the “Special File Room.” Per the initials of the responsible supervisors, the secret location of the Greenbrier bunker stayed put in its super secure haven.[2]

File Room copy

But where were the field offices maintaining their copies of the defense plans and sealed envelopes (aka Appendix 25) and were they secure? Sixteen years after the first envelope was licked, someone finally asked. According to a March 8, 1977 memo, representatives of the Defense Preparedness Agency (a successor agency to OCDM) “wanted reassurance that these sealed envelopes are kept in a safe place and had not been tampered with in any way…” This same memo contained FBI Director Clarence M. Kelley’s request to “All SACS” that each of them confirm “the safe location and integrity of sealed envelopes” and notify FBI headquarters of the results of their inspection by close of business on March 11, 1977.

Scotch Tape copy

Miraculously, most of the field offices had nothing but good news to report back to the Director. A sampling of these routine replies can be viewed here. There was one case in Chicago where one of the sealed envelopes had been “worn on one end and had been sealed with Scotch tape, dated and initialed.” There were a few other anomalies with regard to the envelopes in other offices, but these issues were reported and did not set off any alarm bells. And then there was the case of the Butte, Montana field office.

Butte Postcard_Lo

The Butte office, reputedly a dumping ground for the worst FBI agents in the Bureau,[3] responded to headquarters in a memo that stated that the “envelope must have been inadvertently destroyed when all secret material [was] ground up” when they updated their plans the previous year. They then meekly requested a replacement envelope. The Director was having none of it. He fired back a memo rebutting their shredder excuse and demanded that an “exhaustive search” be conducted with a subsequent report of their efforts. Unfortunately, there is no follow-up memo included in the declassified documents.

Butte_Reprimand copy

Presumably the Butte office received their replacement envelope (and a reprimand) and maintained its integrity until the office was permanently closed in 1989.

There is no evidence contained in the declassified documents released thus far that the FBI was relieved of its notification responsibilities prior to Ted Gup’s published revelation of the existence of the Greenbrier bunker in 1992. It is therefore assumed that the procedure remained in place for the life of the bunker.

Have the field offices been assigned a similar notification task in the years since the decommissioning of the Greenbrier bunker? If there is a new Congressional relocation site, the answer to this question may be yes. After all, the level of trust between the White House and Congress has only declined since 1961.

J Edgar Hoover

REFERENCES

Unless otherwise noted, all of the documents referenced in this post have been excerpted from the following FOIA release:

"Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) war/emergency plans and Bureau assistance for members of Congress in the event of war/emergency, 1955-1977"

Source: Federal Bureau of Investigation
Attn: FOI/PA Request
Record/Information Dissemination Section
170 Marcel Drive
Winchester, VA 22602-4843

To read all of the memos referenced in this post, please see our FBI Congressional Relocation Site Correspondence collection on Scribd.


[1] The redacted government documents referenced in this post do not mention the Greenbrier resort bunker in White Sulphur Springs, West Virginia as the relocation site for the U.S. Congress, but another declassified FBI document we have posted does. See: http://www.scribd.com/doc/102562220/Greenbrier-FBI-Memos-1957.

[2] CONELRAD has filed a Freedom of Information request with the FBI for Bureau File 66-17388 including Appendix 25 with a special note that we would like the contents of the sealed envelope photocopied. We will update this post if and when we receive this documentation.

[3] For a mention of the Butte field office’s bad reputation see page 28 of “From Appalachia to the White House: My Life in the Secret Service” by Joe Dye [Bloomington, IN: CrossBooks, 2011]. See also pages 67, 216 and 396 of “The FBI” by Ronald Kessler [New York: Simon and Schuster, 1994] in which he references the history of the notorious field office.

237 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 237 of 237
Gaurav said...

ketu in 11th house is a good sign. It means that the natives will attain prosperity and everything they desire. It is good for materialistic people.

Unknown said...

Ij start canon and find out the best way to download Canon printer drivers.
Ij.start.cannon | Ij.start.canon

Sysvoot IT Solutions said...

Fix pc security software issues like installation, uninstallation, activation, downloading, and virus removal on Windows and MAC. Speed up your PC performance. Contact antivirus tech support team to get instant help.

roy stalon said...

HP is the well-known manufacturer known for producing great desktops, laptops, printers and other devices. HP has a huge customer base worldwide. For any technical issues you face with HP, you can either visit the official site of HP or get third party technical support number & get connected to the certified HP professionals. The HP Customer Service team can resolve all kinds of issues like PC optimization, printer technical issues, your antivirus conflicting with HP enabled system and a lot more. Once you call on HP numbers, our customer service team will identify the problem and offer the quick solution to you.

Mark Watson said...

The users witness technical issues associated with wifi connection manager Netgear or setup. Now, to setup, you are supposed to plug in extender, then connect your computer or mobile to the extender’s wifi network. Now, you should launch a web browser and then enter mywifiext.net or 192.168 and then click or tap on NEW EXTENDER SETUP. Now, you should choose your extender’s admin credentials and then you must select and answer two security question from the drop-down menu.

Gaurav said...

Mars in 7th House: Exploring its Positives and Negatives effects in Female and Male Horoscope · Exalted Mars in the 7th House makes a person much energetic.

faizaashraf said...

The Winding Path
Ken Kern from The Winding Path. Highly rated, beautiful sleep music deep sleeping music piano music with accompanying instruments with pictures of exquisite flowers and plants.

Classical Indian Music for Healing and Relaxing sleep music deep sleeping musicGayatri Govindarajan, "Pure Deep Meditation" track. Lovely and rhythmic music played on the veena, the most ancient of the Indian plucked-instruments, with nature scenes.

Tech To Review said...

Consumers can watch the most current film and television series releases on 9kmovies Win. Within hours of its release, content is uploaded to the website. It is occasionally possible for users to acquire access to something before it is officially released. When movies depart theatres and OTT platforms, the 9kmovies.cyou website uploads them for download.

Michael B Packer said...

cancel flight ticket etihad airways passengers may find the offline method more reliable. If you need to cancel an etihad airlines flight ticket, you must call a representative. Post connecting your call, you may have to provide your booking information to the officials and ask for a revocation process. Moreover, the agent may proceed with the reversal procedure. In the end, you may be notified through an email once it is done.


Advice Associates said...

eXp Real Estate is the one-stop solution for all your real estate needs.  Real estate Investment is a great way to secure and multiply your hard-earned money. If you have small capital then real estate projects on installments like Galaxy Mall is the best option for you we deal with.

rohitjadhav said...

One stop destination to get the best product review sites india, best electronic reviews site, best home appliances reviews etc. best gadget reviews site

viralabis said...

Thanks for your marvelous posting! I seriously enjoyed reading it, you will be a great author.
I will make sure to bookmark your blog and may come
back later in life. I want to encourage continue your great posts,
have a nice evening!

Solo Mediatama
Viral Abis
Order Lagi
Area Cetak

Nigersaurus teeth said...

In this article we will tell you about Vanilla Icc Net worth, his early life, biography, career, and relationship status.

Forget Icloud Password said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

If you have been facing any issues regarding how to Send Money from Chime to Paypal
contact Email customer service to resolve your issue.

Unknown said...

Cash App direct deposit service is very fast, private, and easy to use. Find your Cash App Bank
is issued by which bank.

Unknown said...

Have you Forget Icloud Password? don't worry contact, contact customer service they will assist you to resolve your issue.

Unknown said...

If you get confused while login to your match account, like forgetting the match account email id or password. Then you can contact the match customer service, as they are available 24/7 for match login issue..

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Customer Support | Live Chat Service said...

How to Fix ATT.net email not working in 2022?

Suppose you are one of the many Americans that rely on ATT as your internet service provider. In that case, you may be having trouble with your email or even logging in to your email from anywhere other than the computer you use daily. There could be various reasons for this, but here is a quick solution to solve the issue of ATT.net email not working 2022. First, delete all cookies, cache, history and temp files- To do this in most browsers, go to the settings menu and find the option to clear your browsing data. Next, select All time and check the boxes for cookies, cache, and history. Once you've done this, restart your browser and try re-accessing your email.

WHY DOES MOZILLA FIREFOX KEEPS NOT RESPONDING?

Firefox offers a more simplified interface and quicker download speeds than Internet Explorer, the most widely used Web browser. Mozilla Firefox can have an issue with the browser files if Firefox is not responding. This issue may also be brought on by low memory due to an excessive number of open tabs. Choose Task Manager by performing a right-click or Ctrl+Shift+Esc on a space on the Windows taskbar. When the Windows Task Manager displays, choose the Processes tab after that. Click End Process after selecting the item for firefox.exe. Select Yes when the "Task Manager Warning" dialogue box displays.

How to Change my Spectrum WiFi Password?

Many Spectrum users are asking how to change my spectrum WiFi password. So, open your web browser, enter your router's IP address into the address box, and then click Enter. You must log in using your Spectrum router's username and password. Then select "Advanced." Next, select the Basic tab. Type a new network name in the "SSID" column to change the Spectrum WiFi password. Next, type a new WiFi password and retype it to confirm. At last, click the 'Apply' button.

CloudInfotech said...

Buy the Grandstream GRP2601P IP Phone from Cloud Infotech. It is a 2-line Essential IP Phone that features 5-way audio conferencing for easy conference calls.

Isabel John said...

Hope the stated content is useful. Thanks for sharing. HP printer setup is not that easy. Yet, to bring it effective via instant support regarding the printer & its related issues- Get HP Printer support instant from our Technical Assistance.

Justin Loiera said...

Great Job, and your blog is very valuable for us. electric cars

Yuvaap FindYourY said...

You may have to use expensive equipment or join a gym to make your body fit, but you can do a full-body workout at home without joining a gym. All you need is a 30-Minute Full-Body Workout of your precious time. This will help you to look very beautiful and curvy.

Bangalore Female Escorts said...

It is up to you to make your journey to Bangalore very sensual. codella

totosafe guide 먹튀검증 said...

After reading this post, we can improve our writing skills and abilities. Here, we can find an informative post. Thanks for your post.

토토 파워볼
토토사이트 카지노

Gb said...

Promot is a powerful and reliable Facebook marketing automation service. It offers features to automate marketing campaigns, post ads, schedule posts, respond to comments, and more. With Promot, you can quickly reach the right people at the right time and maximize the reach of your business. It's a perfect solution for businesses that need to get more out of their Facebook presence. With its comprehensive reporting tools, Promot provides actionable insights and data-driven decisions. Plus, with its easy to use interface, Promot makes managing Facebook campaigns hassle-free and enjoyable. Get started with Promot and start leveraging Facebook for more success today.

Mehndi Designs said...

Home-Refurbishment

Girish said...

Eumaxindia is the no:1 Hoarding agency in Chennai, They are in the industry from 2007

theglobalhues said...

Join Healing Buddha on their remarkable journey as they bridge the gap between ancient energy healing practices and modern wellness techniques.
healingbuddha

Derek Advert said...

The cricket fans residing near R. Premadesa stadium can enjoy the matches live from the stadium. While other people can opt for the Pak vs Afghanistan ODI match live streaming through various official broadcasting channels.

theglobalhues said...

Break barriers and build connections. The Global Hues connects a global community of entrepreneurs, fostering collaboration, innovation, and cross-cultural learning.
theglobalhues

Crypto Talk Blogs said...

Cryptocurrency, cryptocurrencynews, bitcointrading
Tether Wallet Customer Service number If you're experiencing any issues or have questions regarding your Tether Wallet, don't hesitate to reach out to their dedicated customer service team. You can contact Tether Wallet Customer Service at their toll-free number for prompt assistance and reliable support. Your financial security and peace of mind are their top priorities.

Global Assignment Expert said...

Thank you for sharing this informative blog post.
All assignment help is here to save the day! Get the best assignment help in the industry at an unbelievable 35% discount. Our experts will craft an original, custom assignment just for you that meets all your professor's requirements. No more stressing over an impending deadline or pulling all-nighters. Let our experienced writers help you get the grade you need while you focus your time on more important things. Plagiarism is a thing of the past with our 100% original, custom written assignments tailored specifically to your specifications. Save time and money, while gaining peace of mind, with the affordable, high quality assignment assistance from Global Assignment Expert UK.

KEM Builders & Developers said...

KEM Builders new villa projects in Kakkanad - Elegant2

Global Assignment Expert said...

Computer Network assignment help requires proper understanding and strong subject knowledge. The organization Global Assignment Help fulfill all the required guidelines. If you want to boost your learning, our experts are ready to assist you. We provide 100% satisfaction to our clients by offering plagiarism-free content,24/7 live support, Best in Industry Prices,4500+ assignment experts, and many more.

assignment helper said...

If you are looking for a pocket friendly and on time assignment expert, so here we are global assignment expert. Our team of expert assignment will help you with all your assignment and then you will be able to solve and understand that problem. Our team of an expert will help you with your assignment as well as to achieve educational success. Global assignment help has a team of professional and they will help you in all subject related assignment. We deliver our assignment worldwide. Connect with us for more queries and help on our administrative website.

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 237 of 237   Newer› Newest»